The Rebel Jesus 

One of my favorite Christmas songs is Jackson Browne’s “The Rebel Jesus.” It’s not quite a traditional song, but every year, when it’s time for us to start reading Chapter 1 of Luke, there’s something about this song that just – well, I think this song captures something essential about the Christmas story. 

It’s not really a very Christian song.  In fact, in the song, Browne describes himself as “a heathen and a pagan,” but also as someone “on the side of the rebel Jesus.” I don’t agree with everything Browne is saying in the song, but here’s what I think he gets right: so often, our celebrations of Christmas turn very cute-sy very Hallmark-y – this time of year, it’s easy for the Christmas story to be sentimentalized and sanitized, and when we do that, we run the risk of draining the story of its radical message.  Christmas gives us warm and fuzzy feelings, as we celebrate the birth of this baby, and sometimes we forget that this baby grew up to be a man who fought against injustice, challenged dishonest and oppressive political elites, and spoke up against corrupt religious leaders.  Jesus isn’t just an “infant tender and mild” – he is also a rebel, someone who challenges oppressive systems, who overturns exploitation and bigotry of all kinds.  Jesus didn’t just come to comfort us.  He came to challenge us – to challenge everything that is less than it should be, every system that hurts or exploits others.  And every time I listen to “The Rebel Jesus,” I am reminded of that fact, and I’m thankful for it.  This time of year, I want – I need – tidings of comfort and joy.  But “The Rebel Jesus” also reminds me that I need the Jesus who sometimes make me uncomfortable, who sometimes challenges me, who encourages me to give away my possessions, to care for the poor and the hungry and the vulnerable, to live in his upside-down Kingdom where the first are last and the last are first. 

Take a moment to read Luke 1:46-55.  This is the song that Mary sings after she finds out that she’s going to have this baby – after she finds out what God is doing in and through her.  Her song sounds an awful lot like what Jackson Browne is singing.  What’s Jesus about? Lifting up the poor.  Tearing down injustice.  Filling the hungry with good things. 

“Rebel Jesus” challenges a lot of our Christmas traditions and forces us to ask if the real Jesus – the rebel Jesus – would have been welcome at our celebrations.  And then, after a few verses of intense critique, Browne ends the song with words that strike me as really gentle and hopeful: 

But pardon me if I have seemed 
To take the tone of judgement 
For I’ve no wish to come between 
This day and your enjoyment 
In a life of hardship and of earthly toil 
There’s a need for anything that frees us 
So I bid you pleasure and I bid you cheer 
From a heathen and a pagan  
On the side of the rebel Jesus 

So, pardon me if I have seemed to challenge too much about Christmas in this reflection.  I love the season of comfort and joy.  I love the traditions of caroling and hot chocolate and presents.  In a life of hardship, we need them.  And I also love, need, and am challenged by the Jesus who challenged our comfortable habits – the rebel Jesus.  

So, I bid you pleasure, and I bid you cheer, from a pastor who is doing his best to be on the side of the rebel Jesus. 

May Jesus challenge you today and every day.  

-Pastor Brian

You can listen to the full song here: 

Previous
Advent ’23 Entries

Advent23: December 24

A Musical Advent As the Communications Director for Haymarket Church, I get the opportunity to see and read all of the Advent (and also Lent) devotional entries before anyone else. Well, Pastor Brian receives some of them via email before I do … but you get the…

Advent23: December 23

“A shoot will grow up from the stump of Jesse;      a branch will sprout from his roots.  The Lord’s spirit will rest upon him,      a spirit of wisdom and understanding,      a spirit of planning and…

Advent23: December 21

Christmas Breakfast When I think of Christmas, I think of breakfast.  Since I was little, the most central element of my family’s Christmas celebration has been eating a big breakfast together on Christmas morning.  When I was young, it drove me crazy.  We’d come…

Advent23: December 20

Were there Hobbits at the Nativity?  It is no secret in the Bryden household that J.R.R. Tolkien (of the Hobbit, Lord of the Rings, and Silmarillion fame) is my favorite author. While I am not an avid reader, I couldn’t put his books down once I started – with the…

Advent23: December 22

On Sunday in worship, our preacher, Rev. Shannon Hendricks, preached about the story of Mary and Elizabeth (Luke 1:26-56).  In her sermon, she referenced a song called “The Canticle of the Turning.”  This song is a reinterpretation of the song Mary sings…

Advent23: December 18

It was Thanksgiving Week of 1972 when I flew into National Airport to report to my first duty station, Ft. Meade, MD, after completing basic training. I had just turned 18 the previous May and was going to spend my Army stint as a trumpeter in the First US Army…

Advent23: December 17

What must it have been like to be Mary?  Her life got turned upside-down when an angel told her that she was going to give birth to God’s son.  It almost ended her marriage.  It must have strained relationships with family, friends, and neighbors –…

Advent23: December 16

Mary Did You Know? Thirty-plus years ago, my husband, daughter and I were living in Bonn, Germany; at the time Germany’s capital. Bill had been offered a position in Bonn by his employer and we both thought it would be a wonderful opportunity to live in Europe; and…

Advent23: December 15

Mary, Did You Know? Between my husband’s side and mine, we each have 2 siblings who each have at least two children. But while mine are all in Baltimore, Sean’s all live closer to us. We used to split the day of Christmas, Thanksgiving – and all other holidays that…

Advent23: December 14

Finding Home  “Are you going home for the holidays?”  This is a question that I hear many times.  It’s a friendly inquiry but it has taken me years to answer honestly.  I did used to go “home” to CA for the holidays.  When I was married, we…

Advent23: December 13

Where Is The Love? When I was in the last semester of my senior year of high school, I decided to take an online English class. At the time, this was a brand new option; it sounded exciting and easy to just do this class on my own at home on our family computer…

Advent23: December 12

The Sounds of Christmas (A Group entry by our High School Small Group) _______________ Every year on Christmas Eve, ever since I was little, I have watched the Trans-Siberian Orchestra movie with my dad. It has always been the soundtrack to my Christmas and…

Advent23: December 11

For at least a 20+ year period of my life, I had beef with the shepherds from the Nativity story. It all started in the early 2000’s when I was an 11 year-old youngster. As a young, gay, Pentecostal pastor’s kid, my chances for dressing in shiny and bejeweled…

Advent23: December 10

On the second Sunday of Advent, we are talking about John the Baptist.  Advent is kinda weird, in that we prepare for Christmas (at least during early Advent) by telling stories that happened when Jesus was an adult.  We get ready to celebrate the birth…

Advent23: December 9

Over the last week or so, there’s a song I’ve been listening to quite a lot.  It’s called “Thou Who Wast Rich” and the version I’ve been listening to is performed by a group called “Ordinary Time.” There’s nothing fancy about the song – it’s just a hymn, and I…

Advent23: December 8

I love keeping family traditions, especially around Christmas time. Some traditions we have in our family include not listening to Christmas music until afterThanksgiving (although I think one of our daughters starts earlier each year), dipping pretzels inwhite…

Advent23: December 7

“A thrill of hope, the weary world rejoices”  This line from the popular Christmas song, O Holy Night, carried me through the Christmas of 2021. As the world continued to isolate due to COVID-19, I was navigating a challenging diagnosis. By December 2021, my…

Advent23: December 6

Be warned: today’s Advent devotion includes some profanity.  First, an explanation: Advent is a season that is traditionally associated with the biblical genre of apocalypticism.  Apocalypticism (or “apocalyptic” or “apocalypse”) is a genre of literature…

Advent23: December 5

Growing up in Michigan, one of my favorite things was coming out of the Christmas Eve service to a light blanket of snow on the sidewalk. It happened pretty much every Christmas and is a very special memory for me. So, when I moved down to Virginia, I had the…

Advent23: December 4

Every year in December, my Mom would bring out the “Christmas Lamp” to mine and my siblings excited delight.  The vintage 1957 Econolite motion lamp, pictured here, is a paper lantern sitting on a base with a light bulb.  Between the light and…

Advent23: December 3

Advent is a counterintuitive season. It ends with joy joy – joy to the world, joy beyond our ability to fathom it. At the end of Advent comes Christmas, when we celebrate the Light of the World entering into our darkness, the Prince of Peace overcoming our…